Empowering Communities, Advocating Solutions


Source: The Journal News

DEC fracking report raises environmental worries


Posted: July 6, 2011
Originally Published: July 6, 2011

ALBANY — A Friday release from the state Department of Environmental Conservation provided some holiday reading material: 736 pages of proposed regulations to mitigate the environmental damage from hydraulic fracturing.

Now, with environmental and industry groups continuing to analyze the dense contents of the state's latest review of the natural gas stimulation technique, questions have begun to surface on the strength of the DEC's recommendations.

While most green groups say the new version of the Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement, as it's called, is a vast improvement over the DEC's initial 2009 recommendations, some say there's still a ways to go.

Of particular concern is the DEC's consideration of the effect of not just a single gas well, but the cumulative impact of many new wells dotting parts of the state's landscape. While the latest draft includes a more robust discussion and consideration of those effects, some wondered if it might have been included just to appease environmentalists.

"The things that we are always concerned about is the evaluation of a cumulative impact to rural New York, and particularly to areas like the Finger Lakes region," said Adrienne Esposito, executive director of Citizens Campaign for the Environment. "While this (draft) is dramatically improved over the last one, it still doesn't make it comprehensive enough."

High-volume hydrofracking has been on hold in New York, which sits above portions of the gas-rich Marcellus and Utica shale formations, since July 2008, when the DEC began its review. It will remain on hold until a final version of its report is complete, which isn't expected until next year.

Most groups — including the Independent Oil & Gas Association, Environmental Advocates of New York, and the American Petroleum Institute — said they were still reviewing the massive report and declined to offer much comment.

A preliminary version was given to reporters on Friday.

DEC Commissioner Joseph Martens said last week that the report "strikes the right balance between protecting our environment, watersheds, and drinking water and promoting economic development." The technique can be practiced safely, he said, with rigorous safeguards like his department is proposing.

Industry groups and natural-gas proponents say the gas locked in the Marcellus Shale could create jobs and decrease the country's dependence on foreign energy. Critics, however, say hydrofracking can contaminate water supplies and wreak havoc on the environment.

Speaking with reporters after an appearance in Erie County on Tuesday, Gov. Andrew Cuomo said the DEC's latest effort balances the concerns of groups on both sides of the heated debate.

"The report goes a long way toward balancing the economic needs of New York," Cuomo said. "We need to generate jobs, grow the economy, but we also need to protect the environment, and I think the report strikes that balance."

John Felmy, chief economist for the American Petroleum Institute, said that while releasing the latest draft was a positive step from industry's perspective, it would take some time to see if they agree with Cuomo's analysis.

"We have our staff digging through it, but they haven't made it through the whole thing yet," Felmy said. "The devil is in the details for these types of things, of course."